Cayuga Capital Management
People:
Cayuga Capital Management NYC portfolio
$97 million -D7 45%, walkup 43%, C0 5%; Brooklyn 96%, Queens 3%*
1524th largest portfolio by dollar value
186,893 sqft – walkup 56%, D7 33%, mixed-use 9%; Brooklyn 94%, Queens 5%
1638th largest by SF
27 properties – Brooklyn 92%, Queens 7%
377th largest
222 residential units – Brooklyn 94%, Queens 5%
1062th largest by residential units
0 foreclosures, 0 bankruptcies, 4 other court cases.
Company Activity past 24 months:
Seller company: 2 for $34 million
Top Ten Associated Companies:
BLDG Management (2), M&T Bank (2), Spatial Equity (1), EPR Properties (1), Dime Community Bank (1), David Katz (1), Double U Realty (1), Signature Bank (1), Amherst Capital Management (1), Bridgeinvest (1)
Top Ten Associated People:
Lloyd Goldman (2), Alexis Perrotta (1), Gregory E. Zimmerman (1), Louis Ciniglio (1), David Katz (1), Michael Weitzman (1), Alex Horn (1), Shulem Herman (1), David Traitel (1), Samuel Teitelbaum (1)
Recent activity as company:
• Cayuga Capital Management sold 723 Van Sinderen Avenue for $7 million to Spatial Equity on October 22, 2025.
• Cayuga Capital Management sold 93 North 10 Street for $26.9 million to BLDG Management on November 14, 2024.
• Cayuga Capital Management borrowed $8.2 million from Dime Community Bank for 291 Wyckoff Avenue on March 26, 2024.
• Cayuga Capital Management sold 16 Berry Street for $8.2 million to Samuel Teitelbaum on June 08, 2023.
• SMS Financial on May 09, 2023 bought a loan with an original principal of $6.1 million from Customers Bank, signed by Kimberly A. Stack, secured by 294 Harman Street, when owned by Cayuga Capital Management.
• Cayuga Capital Management sold 116 Banker Street for $43.3 million to EPR Properties on February 28, 2023.
• Barbara Hershman sold 116 Banker Street for $24.8 million to Cayuga Capital Management on February 16, 2023.
• Cayuga Capital Management sold 199 Starr Street for $8.5 million to Shulem Herman on February 15, 2023.
• Cayuga Capital Management sold 88 North 11 Street for $20 million to Double U Realty on June 22, 2022.
• Cayuga Capital Management borrowed $30 million from Bridgeinvest for 116 Banker Street on December 23, 2021.
Latest Stories:
• Spatial Equity pays $7M to Cayuga Capital for dev site in East New York (November 07, 2025)
• Senvest Capital affiliate pays $17.5M to Arel Capital for Bushwick retail (September 25, 2025)
• Double U Realty pays $8.9M for dev site in Greenpoint (February 03, 2025)
• Lender BLDG acquires office properties in Williamsburg from Cayuga for $26.9M (December 03, 2024)
• Double U files plans for 89K sf sports center in Williamsburg (August 12, 2024)
• Cayuga Capital files plans for 167-unit building in East New York (June 07, 2024)
• SMS Financial buys $6.1M note on two Bushwick walkups (May 22, 2023)
Court Records:
Properties: