City Skyline Realty
507 W 139th St Ste A. New York, NY 10031
People:
City Skyline Realty NYC portfolio
$241.4 million -walkup 74%, elevator 25%; Manhattan 75%, Bronx 24%*
844th largest portfolio by dollar value
1,029,163 sqft – walkup 71%, elevator 28%; Manhattan 62%, Bronx 37%
472th largest by SF
43 properties – Manhattan 79%, Bronx 20%
217th largest
1,220 residential units – Manhattan 65%, Bronx 34%
277th largest by residential units
40 foreclosures, 0 bankruptcies, 0 other court cases.
Company Activity past 24 months:
Seller company: 4 for $8.4 million
Borrower company: 1 for $0
Top Ten Associated Companies:
Arbor Realty Trust (6), Signature Bank (3), Allegiance Financial Group (2), Midwest Financial (2), Oscar Puerta (1), Fannie Mae (1), New York Community Bank (1), ConnectOne Bank (1)
Top Ten Associated People:
Timothy P. Sheehan (2), Oscar Puerta (1), Rodney G. Roe (1), Dave Ellingrud (1), Konstantinos Venetsanakos (1)
Recent activity as company:
• City Skyline Realty sold 53 Hamilton Place for $2.2 million to Fannie Mae on January 02, 2026.
• City Skyline Realty sold 26 Macombs Place for $750,000 to Midwest Financial on October 15, 2025.
• City Skyline Realty sold 2710 Morris Avenue for $1,000,000 to Allegiance Financial Group and Midwest Financial on June 09, 2025.
• City Skyline Realty sold 2707 Morris Avenue for $4.5 million to Oscar Puerta on April 01, 2025.
• Allegiance Financial Group on June 28, 2024 bought a loan with an original principal of $8.1 million from Peapack-Gladstone Bank, signed by John O’Gorman, secured by 26 Macombs Place, when owned by City Skyline Realty.
• Barberry Rose Management Company sold 713 West 180 Street for $2.9 million to City Skyline Realty on September 09, 2022.
• East Coast Holdings sold 324 East 126 Street for $7.5 million to City Skyline Realty on August 08, 2022.
• City Skyline Realty borrowed $5.7 million from Signature Bank for 324 East 126 Street on August 08, 2022.
• Maurice Kavanagh sold 864 East 149 Street for $6.4 million to City Skyline Realty on July 26, 2022.
• John D. Balian sold 514 West 151 Street for $6.1 million to City Skyline Realty on February 04, 2022.
Latest Stories:
• Oscar Puerta pays $4.5M for two walkups in Fordham Manor in foreclosure (April 11, 2025)
• Fannie Mae files $72.3M pre-foreclosure against 11 NYC rentals (October 31, 2023)
• $26M in pre-foreclosure filings at City Skyline Realty rentals in Harlem (September 05, 2023)
• $10M pre-foreclosure filed at 61-unit rental in Fordham Manor (June 12, 2023)
• City Skyline pays $7.5M to East Coast Holdings for three walkups in East Harlem (August 15, 2022)
• City Skyline Realty pays $6.4M for 43-unit rental in Mott Haven (August 09, 2022)
Court Records:
Properties: